10 Comments
User's avatar
Kristi Coulter's avatar

Gina, this is INCREDIBLE.

Expand full comment
Sharon Liveten's avatar

It took me a while to read this because I was so incredibly sad that I couldn't see the show in Los Angeles, and I knew I was missing out. I love Big Star, but the music always brings the feelings to me, the ones similar to yours as well as much darker ones. It's music that is important to me.

I am so glad I read this, so well put. As usual.

Expand full comment
Robert Kovar's avatar

I love this. I went to see them at the last minute too, and found the show unexpectedly moving. Hearing those songs live was almost an out-of-the-body experience. Patrick Sansone in particular was a revelation- but all the musicians took a turn at taking my breath away.

Expand full comment
Sarah N's avatar

I'm coming late to this, via a recommendation from Caryn Rose, and wanted to say--I was at that same show, and I felt like it was time travel to a shared imaginary space. To the space with Chilton and Bell and Hummel, as you said; to the space where they made those records; to the places where Mills and Auerbach and Sansone and Stamey first heard them and dreamed; to a place outside the Live-Nation-ization of concerts (no QR codes, no $18 beers, just heat and sweat and a walk through the Tenderloin). I can't believe the signed posters were only $30 each. I've paid more for a t-shirt. It's hanging up in my hall now.

Expand full comment
Gina Arnold's avatar

Such a great show, wasn't it? I felt exactly the same. I almost didn't go, just a last minute ask from a friend with a spare ticket, too.

Expand full comment
John Nogowski's avatar

Is THE Gina Arnold writing her ass off about The Replacements so beautifully??

Expand full comment
AB1977's avatar

Timeless is the perfect way to describe Big Star's music

Expand full comment
Kevin Salem's avatar

Love

Expand full comment
Peter Haas's avatar

Another wonderful piece. Nice to know such experiences are still out there!

Expand full comment
Linda Champagne's avatar

I so wish I was there too!

Expand full comment